Unsung heroes

(Due to circumstances that will remain an enigma, this will be my last post on this space for a while. Moving forward, any posts I make will have to be ad-hoc as opposed to the 2-3 a week I’ve kept up for the past 5 months. What that will mean, only time will tell.)

We’ve successfully brought single-player aspects into MMOs, and with them has come the single-player mentality. It’s why I think Pokemon Go is the future of MMOs– not because it’s a technical marvel or a new frontier in storytelling or raids or whatever, but because it’s building on the original promise of the MMO: get out there and meet new people in this game, who will be your friends and allies on a great big adventure that YOU set the goals of.

– Tamrielo, Playing the Modern MMO (Digital Initiative)

I almost cheered at this post when I saw it a while back – until I reread that paragraph above. ‘That you set the goals of’?

My immediate reaction: what sort of multiplayer are we talking about here?

To most folks, I think, multiplayer in an MMO is about conquering challenges together in the world – challenges that everyone has a stake in conquering, be it dungeons, or group quests, or heart-crushing horrors like Guild Wars 2‘s infernal jumping puzzles. Counting one party member’s adventure among these is new to me.

Not new to veterans of Tyria, of course, since GW2’s Personal Story allows ‘guesting’. But said guests might as well be expendable NPCs for all the notice the story takes of their presence, and that’s always felt like less of an adventure to me than it could be.

MMOs all handle this aspect of the ‘adventure’ differently. Some, like GW2, cater to groups – this works where there is exclusive (race/class-specific) content, so everyone gets a shot at what they’re missing out on. Others, like The Lord of the Rings Online and The Elder Scrolls Online, do it the classic way, where the main story is something all players experience, on a global level, and with no distinction made between individual participants.

On one hand, the latter creates an environment where players have the freedom to tackle story content without any obligation to group up. Not something, I feel, that should be advocated, and yet it is – because on the other, this is also where the reviled solo-only quests come in, and no amount of rationalizing will do away with the fact that, you know, they’re solo-only.

Not only do they interrupt the all-important collaboration, they can be enormously frustrating to less skilled players who need that collaboration to survive the game’s mechanical challenges in the first place. I find myself recalling a friend, a casual who played a Lore-master in LoTRO’s Rise of Isengard days, and how he nearly dumped the game upon hitting the brick wall that was Saruman’s ambush of the Rohirrim in the Ring of Isengard. None of us could lend a hand – because it was his show. It was a textbook example of game mechanics interfering with the story experience.

The other issue is, again, that none of these approaches truly account for the presence of other players. In the context of the adventure itself, we’re still the protagonists, saving the world all by ourselves, and our friends are just extras. While functional, I can’t help feeling the emptiness of it.

If the idea is emergent gameplay, telling our own stories through spontaneous collaboration, the premise of one man leading the charge (leaving aside the joke of solo-only) works. But if we’re going to bring in the single-player side of the story (pun intended) at all, perhaps we ought to go all the way.

Like Zubon at Kill Ten Rats wrote, certain things in a game should not receive positive reinforcement. I don’t doubt there are many who consider MMO soloing one.

9 Responses to “Unsung heroes”

  1. I totally agree. Im baffled by the fact main story in ESO is solo only o.o And yet my old mum can manage it, she is a lot higher level than me…. im stuck at 45 while she is far in veteran ranks (:

    My god i will miss you!! Whyyyy!!? Please come back soonish :’)
    Take care, huggss xxx

    • Yeah, TESO’s lack of main quest guesting was confounding. But then, the way they wrote it, there’s no way anybody but the One Great Chosen One of Destiny and Fate could be taking down Molag Bal at the end. Unless the guests were there just to be cheerleaders.

      Thank you, take care too. =) I’ll still be about, reading and commenting, just that I’ve had to scale back actual blogging.

  2. Tho its good they make them possible to solo i think… a lot of ppl dont like to group, like mum. She always solo…. they need paying costumers. But some content should be impossible to solo ofc.

  3. It’s a shame to see less posts from you, but 2-3 a week is a lot to keep up with (at least in my experience). Hope everything is alright there!

    • Thanks, Rav. I hope things get better sooner rather than later too! In the meantime, email notifications mean I can still keep up with what everyone else is talking about, so I continue to look forward to your posts. =D

      • *pops in* *looks around* “Still empty?” *leaves again*

        Hope things are (getting) better. You’re missed!

      • Hey Rav/griffon person! What a surprise. Stuff’s pretty much still the same, excccccept I’m both off MMOs and more involved over at Storium now – and therefore wondering what else I can do here that still adds up. Thanks for swinging by, though, much appreciated!

  4. I was doing 2-3 times a week, which lead to me having to hiatus for a while. I am aiming for 2-3 times a month now =) Yeah, that means less readers but I mostly write for the joy of it – any discussions that arise are just bonus!

    I like what you are saying here but there is this weird space of MMOs that should have been single player games to begin with. The best example of that is The Secret World. I love it. It’s fun. I don’t need (or want) to group in it. Some would argue elements of SWTOR as well. Some games are better left single player instead of jammed into a MMO space.

    • Right on! And yeah, I didn’t think of those two. SWTOR tries pretty hard to cater to the guests, but IMHO, using RNG to determine who gets to determine conversation paths is… iffy. No idea about TSW since I missed that boat, but I reckon guesting there plays out just like in any other MMO – only the setting caters much more to emergent gameplay.

Shtay a while, and... talk!

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: